Colts vs. Steelers Final Score & Odds RecapThe Steelers beat the Colts 34–22 at home
Indianapolis Colts at Pittsburgh Steelers, Sunday, Oct 11. Final: Colts 22, Steelers 34. Kalshi, Polymarket US and Polymarket settled the game on Pittsburgh. Trading has closed on Gemini, and it hasn't reported a result yet.
Settled on Kalshi (Oct 11, 4:11 PM ET), Polymarket US (Oct 11, 4:15 PM ET) and Polymarket (Oct 11, 4:28 PM ET)
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | T | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IND | 6 | 7 | 6 | 3 | 22 |
| PIT | 7 | 10 | 7 | 10 | 34 |
Get your $55 Bonus
1st 8:45: A.Rodgers pass short right to J.Warren for 80 yards, TOUCHDOWN [G.Stewart]. C.Bo…
On every market we track on it (winner, spread, total, quarters, props and more), across Kalshi, Polymarket US and Polymarket. Kalshi’s share is its own volume, $1 a contract.
How the markets called it
At kickoff- Kalshi41%60%
- Polymarket US41%59%
Steelers won as the favorite, 34–22.
- Spread
- PIT −2.5Steelers covered
- Total
- 41.5Over: 56 points
Each venue’s last price for each team at or before 12:50 PM ET, 10 minutes before kickoff; the spread and total are Kalshi’s lines priced closest to even. No price from Polymarket by then.
Money traded
$20M in all · 163,545 trades- Kalshi$18M92%
- Polymarket US$821k4%
- Polymarket$797k4%
Kalshi, by bet type
- Winner$7.2M40%
- Spread$3.5M20%
- Total points$2.1M12%
- Quarters and halves$639k4%
- Player props$4.2M24%
- Everything else$274k2%
Every market we track on the game (winner, spread, total, quarters and halves, player props and the rest), from each market’s opening to settlement. Parlays aren’t counted. Kalshi’s figure is its own volume, as Kalshi shows it: contracts traded, each counted at its $1 payout (our data partner AllTop’s count of every Kalshi trade on the game’s markets). Polymarket’s and Polymarket US’s are dollars paid for their contracts (price times contracts), as our data partner AllTop reports each trade. The total adds the three.
Biggest trades
- $70k on the Steelers at 99¢Polymarket US · Sun 3:50 PM · 2 fills
- $49k on the Steelers at 89¢Kalshi · Sun 3:42 PM · 2 fills
- $40k on the Steelers at 99¢Kalshi · Sun 3:51 PM
- $35k on the Colts at 35¢Kalshi · Sun 1:51 PM · 2 fills
- $33k on the Steelers at 66¢Kalshi · Sun 1:41 PM
- $30k traded on the Steelers at 65¢Polymarket · Sun 2:29 PM
- $30k on the Steelers at 59¢Kalshi · Sun 6:48 AM
- $30k on the Steelers at 59¢Kalshi · Sun 2:18 PM
On the winner market, any time before settlement. Polymarket doesn’t say which side its buyer took, so its trades show the team traded.
Quarter & half winners
Kalshi, settled- 1st quarterPIT
- 2nd quarterPIT
- 3rd quarterPIT
- 4th quarterPIT
- 1st halfPIT
- 2nd halfPIT
Player props
Kalshi, settled- Jonathan TaylorMissedIND · 1+ TD0 TD318,665 contracts traded
- Travis HomerMissedPIT · 1+ TD211,295 contracts traded
- Germie BernardMissedPIT · 1+ TD0 TD180,337 contracts traded
- Aaron RodgersMissedPIT · 2+ TD0 TD80,358 contracts traded
- Jaylen WarrenHitPIT · 60+ rush yds101 rush yds74,178 contracts traded
- Pat FreiermuthHitPIT · 1+ TD2 TD68,004 contracts traded
Each player’s most-traded prop on Kalshi, as it settled.
- Steelers drive4 plays, 9 yards, 2:35End
- Q4 0:354:082nd & 11 at IND 44M.Rudolph kneels to IND 45 for -1 yards.—1.5¢→1.5¢
- Q4 1:144:071st & 10 at IND 43M.Rudolph kneels to IND 44 for -1 yards.—1.5¢→1.5¢
- Q4 2:004:062nd & 4 at IND 48J.Warren right guard to IND 43 for 5 yards (C.Ward; G.Gumbs).—1.5¢→1.5¢
- Q4 2:004:03Two-Minute Warning
- Q4 2:354:021st & 10 at PIT 46J.Warren up the middle to IND 48 for 6 yards (C.Bynum).—1.5¢→1.5¢
- Colts drive6 plays, 19 yards, 1:08Downs
- Q4 2:414:014th & 15 at PIT 46D.Jones pass incomplete short right to K.Allen (A.Samuel).—1.5¢→1.5¢$15k traded1% INDESPN 0% IND
- Q4 2:414:014th & 10 at PIT 41PENALTY on IND, Delay of Game, 5 yards, enforced at PIT 41 - No Play.—1.5¢→1.5¢$8.1k traded2% INDESPN 1% IND
- Q4 2:464:003rd & 10 at PIT 41D.Jones pass incomplete deep left to D.Burks.—1.5¢→1.5¢$20k traded1% INDESPN 1% IND
- Q4 2:523:592nd & 10 at PIT 41D.Jones pass incomplete deep left to L.Treadwell.—1.5¢→1.5¢$5.3k traded3% INDESPN 2% IND
- Q4 2:583:581st & 10 at PIT 41D.Jones pass incomplete deep middle to J.Downs (J.Brisker).IND −1¢2.5¢→1.5¢$4.9k traded4% INDESPN 2% IND
- Q4 3:203:581st & 10 at IND 49D.Jones pass short left to K.Allen to PIT 41 for 10 yards (J.Brisker).—2.5¢→2.5¢$27k traded1% INDESPN 3% IND
- Q4 3:433:581st & 10 at IND 35D.Jones pass short middle to K.Allen to IND 49 for 14 yards (J.Ramsey). ** Injury Update: IND-J.Travis has returned to the game.IND +1¢1.5¢→2.5¢$14k traded3% INDESPN 2% IND
- Q4 3:433:57C.Boswell kicks 65 yards from PIT 35 to end zone, Touchback to the IND 35.
- Steelers drive4 plays, 3 yards, 0:29FG
- Q4 3:433:564th & 7 at IND 36PIT 22–34C.Boswell 54 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-C.Kuntz, Holder-C.Johnston.—1.5¢→1.5¢$13k traded1% INDESPN 1% IND
- 3:55PM US$10k on the Steelers at 97.8¢, $11k if they winPIT
- Q4 3:473:55Timeout #3 by IND at 03:47.
- 3:55KalshiPIT
2 big bets · $25k all on the Steelers
- 3:55 · $10k on the Steelers at 97¢
- 3:55 · $15k on the Steelers at 97¢
- Q4 3:523:553rd & 7 at IND 36J.Warren left tackle to IND 36 for no gain (A.Haulcy).IND +1¢1.5¢→2.5¢$61k traded2% INDESPN 3% IND
- Q4 3:523:54Timeout #1 by PIT at 03:52.
- Q4 3:523:53Timeout #2 by IND at 03:52.
- Q4 4:003:522nd & 14 at IND 43A.Rodgers pass short left to G.Bernard to IND 36 for 7 yards (A.Davis-Gaither).—1.5¢→1.5¢$12k traded1% INDESPN 2% IND
- Q4 4:003:52Timeout #1 by IND at 04:00.
- Q4 4:063:511st & 20 at IND 49J.Warren right guard to IND 43 for 6 yards (D.Buckner; C.Ward).—1.5¢→1.5¢$5.9k traded24% INDESPN 2% IND
- 3:51Kalshi$40k on the Steelers at 99¢, $40k if they winPIT
- Q4 4:123:501st & 10 at IND 39J.Warren left tackle to IND 38 for 1 yard (C.Bynum).PENALTY on PIT-T.Fautanu, Offensive Holding, 10 yards, enforced at IND 39 - No Play.—1.5¢→1.5¢$84k traded1% INDESPN 2% IND
- 3:50Kalshi · PM USPIT
4 big bets · $92k all on the Steelers
- 3:50 · $10k on the Steelers at 99¢
- 3:50 · $55k on the Steelers at 99¢
- 3:50 · $15k on the Steelers at 99¢
- 3:50 · $13k on the Steelers at 98.5¢
- Colts drive8 plays, 4 yards, 2:23Downs
- Q4 4:123:49Official Timeout at 04:12.
- Q4 4:173:494th & 17 at IND 39D.Jones pass incomplete deep left to J.Downs (P.Wilson).IND −2¢3.5¢→1.5¢$95k traded2% INDESPN 1% IND
- Q4 4:233:483rd & 17 at IND 39D.Jones pass incomplete deep left [K.Benton].—3.5¢→3.5¢$150k traded1% INDESPN 2% IND
- Q4 4:283:473rd & 7 at IND 49D.Jones pass short right to J.Downs pushed ob at PIT 43 for 8 yards (R.Spears-Jennings).PENALTY on IND-T.Bortolini, Offensive Holding, 10 yards, enforced at IND 49 - No Play.IND −2¢5.5¢→3.5¢$25k traded3% INDESPN 3% IND
- Q4 4:343:462nd & 10 at IND 46D.Jones pass short left to S.McGowan pushed ob at IND 49 for 3 yards (P.Wilson).IND −4¢9.5¢→5.5¢$62k traded3% INDESPN 6% IND
- Q4 4:343:44Official Timeout at 04:34.
- Q4 4:423:441st & 10 at IND 46D.Jones pass incomplete deep left to D.Burks (D.Everette). IND-J.Travis was injured during the play.—9.5¢→9.5¢$20k traded10% INDESPN 7% IND
- Q4 5:133:434th & 3 at IND 42D.Jones pass short left to K.Allen to IND 46 for 4 yards (D.Everette).IND −2¢11.5¢→9.5¢$38k traded10% INDESPN 10% IND
- Q4 5:173:423rd & 3 at IND 42D.Jones pass incomplete short middle to K.Allen (K.Benton).—11.5¢→11.5¢$17k traded8% INDESPN 3% IND
- 3:42KalshiPIT
2 big bets · $49k all on the Steelers
- 3:42 · $27k on the Steelers at 89¢
- 3:42 · $22k on the Steelers at 89¢
- Q4 6:003:422nd & 2 at IND 43D.Jones sacked at IND 42 for -1 yards (C.Heyward).—11.5¢→11.5¢$101k traded1% INDESPN 9% IND
- Q4 6:353:411st & 10 at IND 35D.Jones pass short left to J.Taylor to IND 43 for 8 yards (P.Wilson; J.Ramsey).—11.5¢→11.5¢$22k traded10% INDESPN 13% IND
- Q4 6:353:40C.Boswell kicks 65 yards from PIT 35 to end zone, Touchback to the IND 35.
- 3:39Kalshi · PM USPIT
2 big bets · $21k all on the Steelers
- 3:39 · $10k on the Steelers at 90¢
- 3:38 · $11k on the Steelers at 89.5¢
- Steelers drive10 plays, 64 yards, 5:07TD
- Q4 6:353:38Official Timeout at 06:35.
- Q4 6:353:373rd & 6 at IND 17PIT 22–31A.Rodgers pass short middle to P.Freiermuth for 17 yards, TOUCHDOWN. C.Boswell extra point is GOOD, Center-C.Kuntz, Holder-C.Johnston.—22.5¢→22.5¢$36k traded15% INDESPN 8% IND
- Q4 6:483:362nd & 6 at IND 17A.Rodgers pass incomplete short right to G.Bernard.—22.5¢→22.5¢$14k traded12% INDESPN 23% IND
- Q4 7:313:351st & 10 at IND 21J.Warren left guard to IND 17 for 4 yards (G.Stewart; C.Allen).IND +1¢21.5¢→22.5¢$35k traded11% INDESPN 21% IND
- Q4 7:563:354th & 1 at IND 22J.Warren left guard to IND 21 for 1 yard (D.Buckner).IND −8¢29.5¢→21.5¢$15k traded42% INDESPN 21% IND
- Q4 8:033:343rd & 1 at IND 22A.Rodgers pass incomplete deep right to P.Freiermuth.—29.5¢→29.5¢$14k traded15% INDESPN 31% IND
- Q4 8:493:332nd & 1 at IND 22J.Warren left guard to IND 22 for no gain (J.Walley; G.Stewart).IND +6¢23.5¢→29.5¢$40k traded30% INDESPN 22% IND
- Q4 9:313:331st & 10 at IND 31J.Warren up the middle to IND 22 for 9 yards (G.Stewart).IND −2¢25.5¢→23.5¢$31k traded31% INDESPN 21% IND
- Q4 10:113:323rd & 2 at PIT 44A.Rodgers pass short left to G.Bernard ran ob at IND 31 for 25 yards (A.Haulcy).IND −10¢35.5¢→25.5¢$36k traded12% INDESPN 27% IND
- Q4 10:553:312nd & 4 at PIT 42J.Warren right tackle to PIT 44 for 2 yards (C.Ward).—35.5¢→35.5¢$12k traded37% INDESPN 35% IND
- Q4 11:383:301st & 10 at PIT 36A.Rodgers pass short right to J.Warren to PIT 42 for 6 yards (G.Gumbs).IND +2¢33.5¢→35.5¢$16k traded35% INDESPN 35% IND
- Q4 11:423:30R.Sanchez kicks 55 yards from IND 35 to PIT 10. K.Wetjen to PIT 36 for 26 yards (C.Curry; A.Ajiake).
- Colts drive12 plays, 51 yards, 4:29FG
- Q4 11:423:27Official Timeout at 11:42.
- Q4 11:423:274th & Goal at PIT 10IND 22–24S.Shrader 28 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-L.Rhodes, Holder-R.Sanchez.IND −2¢36.5¢→34.5¢$15k traded21% INDESPN 39% IND
- Q4 11:503:263rd & Goal at PIT 10D.Jones pass incomplete short right to T.Warren (A.Samuel).—36.5¢→36.5¢$18k traded24% INDESPN 37% IND
- Q4 11:553:252nd & Goal at PIT 10D.Jones pass incomplete short left to J.Taylor.IND −4¢40.5¢→36.5¢$24k traded69% INDESPN 41% IND
- Q4 12:003:251st & Goal at PIT 10D.Jones pass incomplete short middle to L.Treadwell (J.Brisker).—40.5¢→40.5¢$35k traded64% INDESPN 44% IND
- Q4 12:353:242nd & 6 at PIT 30J.Taylor left tackle pushed ob at PIT 10 for 20 yards (A.Samuel).—40.5¢→40.5¢$37k traded39% INDESPN 50% IND
- Q4 13:123:231st & 10 at PIT 34J.Taylor right end to PIT 30 for 4 yards (J.Sawyer).—40.5¢→40.5¢$8.9k traded91% INDESPN 41% IND
- Q4 13:443:233rd & 2 at PIT 37J.Taylor left end pushed ob at PIT 34 for 3 yards (D.Everette).IND +3¢37.5¢→40.5¢$22k traded75% INDESPN 41% IND
- Q4 14:223:222nd & 10 at PIT 45D.Jones pass short middle to K.Allen to PIT 37 for 8 yards (J.Brisker).—37.5¢→37.5¢$6.0k traded51% INDESPN 40% IND
- Q4 14:273:211st & 10 at PIT 45D.Jones pass incomplete deep left to L.Treadwell.IND +1¢36.5¢→37.5¢$19k traded79% INDESPN 35% IND
- Q4 15:003:213rd & 1 at IND 48D.Jones pass short left to M.Alie-Cox ran ob at PIT 45 for 7 yards.—36.5¢→36.5¢$64k traded74% INDESPN 39% IND
Colts vs. Steelers moneyline
Kalshi: SettledPolymarket US: SettledPolymarket: SettledGemini: Closed Source: Kalshi / Polymarket US / Polymarket / Gemini via DeFi Rate, observed between Oct 11, 4:15 PM and 11:12 PM ET.
Source: Kalshi daily close via DeFi Rate, Sep 29 to Oct 10 (UTC days). A day without a close is left out.
How the Colts vs. Steelers spread and total settled
Kalshi's results for the lines either side of where each ladder settled.
| 11+ pts | Settled Yes |
|---|---|
| 14+ pts | Settled No |
All 25 spread lines
| Colts 2+ pts | Settled No |
|---|---|
| Colts 3+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 4+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 5+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 6+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 7+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 8+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 10+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 11+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 14+ pts | Settled No |
| Colts 15+ pts | Settled No |
| Steelers 2+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 3+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 4+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 5+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 6+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 7+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 8+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 10+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 11+ pts | Settled Yes |
| Steelers 14+ pts | Settled No |
| Steelers 15+ pts | Settled No |
| Steelers 17+ pts | Settled No |
| Steelers 18+ pts | Settled No |
| Steelers 21+ pts | Settled No |
| 55.5 | Settled Yes |
|---|---|
| 58.5 | Settled No |
All 21 total lines
| 22.5 | Settled Yes |
|---|---|
| 25.5 | Settled Yes |
| 28.5 | Settled Yes |
| 31.5 | Settled Yes |
| 34.5 | Settled Yes |
| 37.5 | Settled Yes |
| 40.5 | Settled Yes |
| 41.5 | Settled Yes |
| 42.5 | Settled Yes |
| 43.5 | Settled Yes |
| 44.5 | Settled Yes |
| 45.5 | Settled Yes |
| 46.5 | Settled Yes |
| 49.5 | Settled Yes |
| 52.5 | Settled Yes |
| 55.5 | Settled Yes |
| 58.5 | Settled No |
| 61.5 | Settled No |
| 64.5 | Settled No |
| 67.5 | Settled No |
| 70.5 | Settled No |
Settled Source: Kalshi via DeFi Rate, observed between Oct 11, 3:07 PM and 4:20 PM ET.
NFL Week 5 games 15 games
- FinalTB Buccaneers24DAL Cowboys16$148M traded
- FinalPHI Eagles17JAC Jaguars19$98M traded
- FinalCHI Bears7GB Packers31$31M traded
- FinalCIN Bengals31MIA Dolphins24$22M traded
- FinalCLE Browns12NYJ Jets17$36M traded
- FinalHOU Texans26TEN Titans3$20M traded
- FinalThis gameIND Colts22PIT Steelers34$20M traded
- FinalLV Raiders17NE Patriots45$32M traded
- FinalMIN Vikings23NO Saints13$27M traded
- FinalNYG Giants27WAS Commanders27$44M traded
- FinalDEN Broncos23LAC Chargers17$53M traded
- FinalDET Lions45ARI Cardinals21$37M traded
- FinalSF 49ers32SEA Seahawks29$85M traded
- FinalBAL Ravens30ATL Falcons23$150M traded
- FinalBUF Bills37LAR Rams34$198M traded
Archived prediction market coverage for the Indianapolis Colts at the Pittsburgh Steelers, Sunday, Oct. 11, 1 p.m. ET. The final score and market results are shown above; the original pregame analysis is preserved below.
Pregame analysis
This analysis was published before kickoff. The final score and market results are shown above.
Pittsburgh’s price hasn’t moved in a week. The real trading is about three points.
Kalshi opened the Steelers at 56.5% to beat the Colts on Sept. 29. A week of trading later, the price is 56.5%. No other Week 5 game’s Kalshi price is exactly where it started.
That isn’t because the game is being ignored. The money has gone somewhere else. This is the only game this week where more has been traded on the spread than on who wins: $79,544 against $30,558. Of every dollar traded on this game, about 66 cents is on the spread. In no other Week 5 game is it even half.
Nobody wants to pick a winner
Put simply, the market expects Pittsburgh to win slightly more often than not. All four venues have the Steelers between 56.5% and 57%.
The money is split almost as evenly as the price. Of every dollar traded on who wins, about 54 cents is on Pittsburgh. The largest single order on the game is $1,842, buying the Steelers at 55 cents on Sunday evening. For comparison, Buccaneers–Cowboys drew three orders of $243,902 each this week.
Three points is the whole question
The spread line that trades at even money is Pittsburgh by three or more. That’s a line drawn around a field goal, and these two teams keep finishing within one.
Half of their eight games this season were decided by three points or fewer. Pittsburgh beat Cincinnati 30–27 and lost at Cleveland 27–24. Indianapolis lost 33–30 in overtime at Kansas City and beat Houston 19–17.
A Pittsburgh win by a field goal pays the spread. A win by two doesn’t. With games this tight, that single point is worth trading over, and traders have treated it that way.
The over/under barely registers by comparison: 44.5 points, priced as a coin flip, with $8,366 traded.
Where that leaves Sunday
The winner price says this game is close to a coin flip, and traders have taken it at its word. They’ve left that price alone and put their money on the question these teams’ close games keep turning on: whether the margin reaches three.
Trades and prices: Kalshi, Polymarket US, Polymarket and Gemini via DeFi Rate’s market data, as of Oct. 6 at about 5:15 p.m. ET; the tables above show final market statuses and reported results. Results: ESPN, through Week 4.
Kalshi's New York Case Goes Back to State Court, Where a Shutdown Order Could Return
Kalshi Promo Code RATE55: $55 Bonus for Prochazka vs. Stirling
Kalshi Promo Code RATE55: Trade Colts vs. Texans With a $55 Bonus
Kalshi Promo Code RATE: $55 Bonus for Steelers vs. Bengals Props