DeFi RateApp Offers

Fourth Circuit Panel Affirms Maryland District Court's Kalshi Preliminary Injunction Denial

The split ruling upholding the lower court's decision strengthens the precedent that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt state gambling laws in relation to sports event contracts.

maryland state flag in front of courthouse

Another federal appellate court has passed on an opportunity to enjoin a state government from enforcing its gambling laws in the context of sports event contract trading on designated contract markets. This time, a three-judge panel from the United States Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Kalshi in its lawsuit against Maryland officials.

The majority opinion reinforces the growing precedent that preemption arguments related to the US Commodity Exchange Act and state gambling laws are insufficient to warrant injunctive relief. A split decision from the Third Circuit is becoming more of an outlier on that point.

Majority opinion gives Maryland authorities leeway to take action

The panel released its opinion on Tuesday, giving Maryland officials further clearance to take action against Kalshi for offering sports event contracts to people within the state's borders. Kalshi sued Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission Secretary John Martin and other individuals who work for Maryland's government after the commission sent a cease-and-desist demand to Kalshi regarding sports trading.

The district court denied Kalshi's request for a preliminary injunction as part of that lawsuit. That was the decision that Kalshi appealed and the Fourth Circuit panel ruled on Tuesday.

The district court has yet to rule on the merits of Kalshi's lawsuit. Maryland officials have not commented on whether they will pursue enforcement actions against Kalshi while the case is in progress.

Regardless, the decision again proves the frailty of the argument that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) preempts state gambling laws within the context of trading on designated contract markets (DCMs). The Fourth Circuit is now among the majority of appellate courts to discount that theory.

Third Circuit's stance on preemption moves closer to outlier

So far, five of 11 federal circuit courts have weighed in on whether the CEA and other federal securities laws preempt the enforcement of state gambling laws against DCMs registered with the federal government.

  • Second Circuit in Kalshi vs. Cafferelli

  • Third Circuit in Kalshi v. Flaherty

  • Fourth Circuit in Kalshi v. Martin

  • Sixth Circuit in Kalshi v. Orgel

  • Ninth Circuit in Kalshi v. Assad

Of those five, a 2-1 decision in Kalshi v. Flaherty from the Third Circuit is the only decision to accept Kalshi's preemption argument. However, it must be noted that all of these rulings involve opinions on whether to grant preliminary injunctions rather than the full merits of any of these cases.

In his concurrence, Judge Roger Gregory of the Fourth Circuit echoed the sentiments of the judges from the Second, Sixth, and Ninth circuits in Kalshi v. Martin.

"Because the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, I would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland’s concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so. Nor has Kalshi shown that complying with both the CEA and the Maryland law at issue would be impossible or stand as an obstacle to Congress’s objective to create a centralized federal regulatory framework for trading derivative contracts," Gregory wrote. "I therefore conclude that Kalshi has not demonstrated that the CEA preempts Maryland’s sports wagering laws and concur in the judgment affirming the district court."

Judge Dawn Thackery, writing for the majority in Kalshi v. Martin, reached the same conclusion.

"Even assuming the contracts are swaps, Kalshi has not shown that the CEA clearly displaces Maryland’s concurrent authority to regulate sports gambling or that compliance with both federal and state law is impossible. Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so. Here, it has not done so with the clarity our precedents require."

At this point, Kalshi can ask for an en banc hearing (the full Fourth Circuit to review the panel's decision) or appeal this ruling to the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS). That second option is looking favorable for state governments at this time.

Fourth Circuit panel reinforces New Jersey officials' SCOTUS appeal

The state officials from New Jersey that are currently enjoined from enforcing their state laws against Kalshi have already asked SCOTUS to review the Third Circuit panel's split decision. Should SCOTUS take up the case, this decision out of the Fourth Circuit gives them further favorable precedent to draw upon.

Decisions on rulings against or for injunctive relief could yet come from the Fifth, Seventh, Eighth, and 10th circuits, however. If any of them reach similar conclusions as the Third Circuit panel, that changes the national conversation.

At this time, though, the circuit "split" over the CEA preempting state gambling laws in the regulation of DCMs is looking less like a true split and more like two judges with dissenting opinions.