Senate Democrats Demand CFTC Reverse Prediction Market Geofencing Policy
Nine senators want the agency to withdraw or freeze its nationwide-access interpretation and preserve communications with platforms. The letter gives prediction-market critics a concrete oversight issue ahead of Democrats’ takeover of Congress.

Nine Democratic senators are demanding that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) reverse its push against geographic restrictions on prediction markets, arguing that the agency is undermining state and tribal gambling laws and conflicting with active court orders.
In a Monday letter to Chairman Michael Selig, the senators asked the CFTC to withdraw its Nov. 5 interpretation or suspend implementation until litigation is resolved. They also requested preservation of agency records dating to Jan. 1, 2025, including communications on personal email accounts and encrypted or disappearing-message applications. A response is requested by Nov. 23.
The letter moves the post-election oversight debate toward a specific agency decision. As DeFi Rate previously reported on Democrats’ planned congressional oversight push, the incoming majority gives prediction markets critics greater influence over hearings, document requests, and legislation, even as the Trump administration continues to support the industry’s national expansion.
The request does not suspend the CFTC’s interpretation or change any court order. It does, however, put Selig on notice that senators expect to investigate the agency's handling of prediction markets.
Senators challenge the CFTC’s national access argument
The dispute centers on geofencing: restrictions that prevent customers in specified locations from accessing a platform or particular contracts.
The CFTC’s Nov. 5 interpretation addresses designated contract markets, the federally regulated exchanges on which event contracts trade. It gives exchanges 30 days to cease domestic geographic restrictions that violate impartial access requirements or explain to the agency why compliance is not feasible. It also addresses restrictions imposed through intermediaries accessing those exchanges.
“Derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale in order to achieve the purposes set out in the Commodity Exchange Act,” Selig said when announcing the interpretation. “Geographic access restrictions are inconsistent with those purposes and the Act’s impartial access requirements.”
The senators reject that reading.
“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” they wrote.
They argue that the agency is effectively requiring exchanges to offer gambling products nationwide despite restrictions imposed through state law, tribal gaming law and ongoing litigation.
The senators said the CFTC must explicitly protect restrictions adopted to comply with court orders and gaming laws.
Court-ordered restrictions are the immediate flashpoint
The letter points to restrictions affecting Michigan, Nevada, Washington and the lands of two California tribes. The senators cite Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals and Ninth Circuit decisions supporting state enforcement authority, as well as a Ninth Circuit ruling concerning unauthorized Class III gaming on tribal lands in the preliminary-injunction context.
Their concern focuses on the timing of the CFTC’s interpretation.
According to the letter, the agency acted hours after the Northern District of California issued its latest order in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, requiring Kalshi to geofence around the plaintiff’s tribal lands.
“This interpretation raises concerns that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms currently engaged in litigation and encouraging them to violate state and tribal gaming laws,” the senators wrote.
The letter asks for three explicit protections
If the CFTC will not withdraw or freeze the interpretation, the senators want the agency to state that three categories of geographic restrictions do not violate Regulation 38.151(b):
Restrictions imposed by court order.
Restrictions adopted to comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or tribal-state compacts.
Restrictions an exchange adopts voluntarily.
The third category broadens the request beyond compliance with judicial orders. It would also protect an exchange’s voluntary decision to limit access, rather than require it to defend that restriction under the agency’s national-access interpretation.
The letter was signed by all eight senators representing California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington, along with Senate Agriculture Committee Ranking Member Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota. The signatories are:
Maria Cantwell
Catherine Cortez Masto
Amy Klobuchar
Alex Padilla
Gary Peters
Jacky Rosen
Adam Schiff
Elissa Slotkin
Patty Murray
Records request lays groundwork for further oversight
The preservation request is one of the letter’s most consequential elements.
The senators asked the CFTC to retain existing and future records relating to the issues raised, beginning January 1, 2025. Their request covers official and personal email, mobile devices, encrypted or disappearing-message applications, social media, calendars, meeting notes, voicemail and text messages. They also asked the agency to suspend relevant auto-delete functions and notify people controlling potentially relevant records of preservation obligations.
The letter seeks written confirmation that those materials are being preserved. It is not a subpoena, and it does not establish that records have been deleted or improperly withheld.
But it gives any subsequent inquiry a defined subject: how the CFTC developed the interpretation, what communications accompanied it and whether the agency considered existing court restrictions.
That fits the shift outlined in DeFi Rate’s reporting on the incoming Democratic Congress. Hearings and investigative requests can develop before lawmakers agree on a bill restricting the products themselves.
Democratic control increases pressure, not certainty of a ban
The letter arrives as Democrats prepare to take control of both chambers in January. That changes the congressional environment without automatically changing the CFTC’s leadership or the law governing event contracts.
The Agriculture committees have principal responsibility for CFTC oversight. Schiff serves on Senate Agriculture, while Klobuchar signed the letter in her current role as its ranking member. Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s expected Senate Banking chairmanship would provide a separate platform for scrutiny, not control over the CFTC’s principal oversight committee.
As DeFi Rate’s analysis of the election’s effects on prediction markets explained, Democratic proposals also differ substantially. Some lawmakers want to prohibit sports contracts; others have focused on insider trading, consumer safeguards, or narrower restrictions. Democratic control is not evidence of agreement on a single legislative response.
Schiff and Republican Sen. John Curtis have already introduced the Prediction Markets Are Gambling Act, which would prohibit sports and casino-style event contracts on CFTC-registered platforms. That proposal remains separate from Monday’s request to reverse the geofencing interpretation.
For exchanges, those are distinct risks. Congress could investigate the regulator’s conduct, seek stronger safeguards or try to prohibit particular products.
November 23 is the next accountability date
The senators want a prompt response by Nov. 23, including written confirmation that the CFTC is preserving relevant records. That is a congressional response deadline, not a court hearing or an automatic expiration date for the agency’s policy.
The CFTC’s own interpretation retains its separate 30-day timetable for exchanges to remove restrictions that violate impartial-access requirements or explain why compliance is not feasible. The agency says it will consider the facts and circumstances of particular cases when deciding whether to act.
The immediate question is whether Selig withdraws the interpretation, pauses it or provides the explicit protections the senators requested.
The broader political change is already visible. Democrats are moving from general criticism of prediction markets to a documented challenge to the regulator’s decisions, and asking that the communications behind those decisions be preserved before the new Congress begins.
CFTC Sues Louisiana to Block Prediction Market Shutdown as State Fight Escalates
Polymarket Promo Code RATE: Get $25 for Chargers vs. Ravens MNF
Kalshi Promo Code RATE: $55 Bonus for Steelers vs. Bengals Props
Kalshi Promo Code RATE: $55 Bonus for 49ers vs. Cowboys