Federal Judge Denies CFTC's New York Temporary Restraining Order Request
The CFTC's loss means that New York Attorney General Letitia James can move forward with her case in state court and could increase pressure on Kalshi to restrict access for New Yorkers.

A day after a federal judge granted New York Attorney General Letitia James' request to remand her lawsuit against Kalshi back to state court, an emergency bid by the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission to halt that litigation has failed. A different judge denied the commission a requested temporary restraining order on Friday.
While the legal dispute between the commission and New York authorities will continue, the ruling has significant ramifications for Kalshi. It already faces a cease-and-desist order from gambling regulators in New York and James could press for penalties for non-compliance.
Federal judge deems CFTC request insufficient to warrant restraint
DeFiRate has already reported on James' Thursday remand win, and it was that which prompted the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to ask Judge Lorna Schofield of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York to temporarily restrain James and the New York State Gaming Commission (NYSGC) from taking enforcement actions against Kalshi. The CFTC argued that a temporary restraining order (TRO) was necessary to avoid irreparable harm to its status as the exclusive regulator of prediction market trading while its lawsuit against New York state officials is in progress.
However, Schofield ruled that the CFTC failed to demonstrate that it has a sufficient chance of succeeding on the merits of its case against James and others according to Jonathan Stempel of Reuters. For that reason, Schofield denied the TRO.
This ruling does not end the CFTC's case against New York authorities. The court has yet to issue a final judgment in that matter.
The decision does mean that James and the NYSGC can take further actions against Kalshi, though. The parties have already disclosed what that could include.
New York officials seek financial penalties, order curtailing market access
As DeFiRate already reported, James and the NYSGC were moving forward with discovery prior to their litigation in state court being removed to federal court. The remand puts those demands for records related to Kalshi's advertising in the state, activity by users under the age of 21, and trading by people in the state on markets connected to sporting events.
James' complaint asked a state court for an order affecting several types of event contract trading in New York. If the court grants her request, Kalshi's markets tied to many culture, politics, and sports events would officially be considered illegal gambling in the eyes of New York.
James also seeks damages that could amount to $36 billion. As Kalshi makes its headquarters in the state, there could be an impact on Kalshi's physical operations, too.
Kalshi has its own lawsuit against New York officials in progress in federal court. While the court denied it a preliminary injunction, it has yet to rule on the merits of the complaint.
That is just one possible development that could occur from this point forward. Kalshi might also reach settlement with James, but the CFTC's intervention complicates that premise.
CFTC already instructed Kalshi to defy New York state courts
CFTC Chair Michael Selig has insisted upon his interpretation of federal securities laws meaning that designated contract markets (DCMs) like Kalshi must provide the same access to people across the US without regard for state laws. In August, Selig formally ordered DCMs to ignore New York state court orders to restrict access to certain markets for people in the state.
Federal judges have criticized Selig's interpretation in that context. Additionally, members of Congress have called on Selig to reverse the stance.
Regardless, if the state courts allow James/the NYSGC to enforce their cease-and-desist orders or impose a restraining order limiting contract access in New York, Selig may repeat his guidance for Kalshi to defy those orders. Schofield's Friday ruling on the CFTC's TRO is just one step in what will still be a long road of litigation.
Kalshi's New York Case Goes Back to State Court, Where a Shutdown Order Could Return
Kalshi Promo Code RATE55: $55 Bonus for Prochazka vs. Stirling
Rockets vs. Nuggets Player Props: $25 Bonus With Polymarket Code RATE
United States Senate Passes Amended DEATH Bets Act With Provision for CFTC Oversight