DeFi RateApp Offers

Opinion: Courts and Congress Remembered That They Have Jurisdiction Over CFTC Chair Michael Selig. It's Long Overdue.

Federal district judge, group of US senators have finally responded to Selig's attempts to rewrite legislation and manufacture judicial crises in favor of corporations that the CFTC is supposed to be regulating.

united states flag in front of courthouse

The United States Commodity Futures Trading "Commission" (CFTC) under the influence of Michael Selig has taken on the demeanor of the entire executive branch of the US federal government during the second Trump Administration, in that it believes itself not co-equal but "more-equal" to the judiciary and legislative branches. Recent developments suggest that members of Congress and the federal judiciary are beginning to reassert their power to check Selig, though.

A scathing rebuttal of Selig's rulemaking penned by a federal district judge in New York correctly points out Selig's attempt to fit a nonsensical argument square peg into a legal round hole. A letter from nine members of the US Senate calls out Selig's attempts to manipulate circumstances on behalf of the designated contract markets that Selig is supposed to be regulating is a reminder that winter may be coming.

SDNY judge reminds Selig that his exchange-friendly readings of statutes are not law

DeFiRate has already reported on Judge Colleen McMahon's denial of a request for a preliminary injunction request by Ludlow Exchange, LLC (operator of the Novig prediction market platform) that could have barred New York state officials from taking enforcement actions against the exchange. McMahon opined that Ludlow failed to establish that it was likely to succeed on the merits of its case against New York Attorney General Letitia James and others.

In her explanation for that finding, McMahon addressed Ludlow's argument that federal statutes like the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) preempt New York law in regard to its event contracts. McMahon disagreed with that argument and called out Selig's attempts to rewrite those laws via rulemaking.

"Finally, but hardly without significance, the Court need not defer to the CFTC's preferred interpretation, see Loper Bright Enters. v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369, 401 (2024)," McMahon wrote. "In this case it would be particularly inappropriate to give the CFTC's position that Novig's contracts are swaps, but traditional sports bets are not, deference. Both sports event contracts and sports wagers are outcome dependent and have financial consequences for the contracting parties. As a result, the Interim Rule and the proposed rule, announced on the same day, are inherently contradictory and cannot be reconciled. Furthermore, the Commission's sudden change in its longstanding position that sports wagering activity is the province of states appears calculated to influence the outcome of the ongoing litigation on this very issue. Litigation positions are not entitled to any deference at all."

Brittnie Panetta, attorney for Matthews & Associates, elaborates on McMahon's ruling.

"Ludlow Exchange v. James focuses on if the CFTC can claim exclusive federal jurisdiction over sports event contracts only because they are offered on a federally regulated exchange," Panetta explained. "Under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), they would have exclusive jurisdiction over transactions involving swaps traded on designated contract markets, but contracts have to meet statutory definitions of a swap under the CEA first. Judge McMahon’s analysis rejected the argument because their payouts depend on the outcome of an event. The event has to be associated with a financial/commercial consequence within the meaning of the Act. The court concluded that the sports contracts at issue did not satisfy that requirement and were likely outside the CFTC’s jurisdiction."

Mere days later, members of a US Senate that has mostly abdicated its duty to act as a check against the Trump Administration finally began to take on that role.

Senators' letter to Selig features more direct characterization of manipulation

As DeFiRate's previous reporting highlights, a group of nine current US senators sent a letter to Selig. Three of the nine signatories currently sit on the Senate Committee for Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry.

That committee has oversight of Selig in his operation of the CFT"C" (one person is not a commission). The letter was in reference to an interpretation of federal law that Selig published on Nov. 5.

DeFiRate's earlier reporting explains how that interpretation demanded that designated contract market (DCM) operators end geographical restrictions that the DCMs put in place to comply with court orders and in response to demands from state authorities. The senators wrote:

"The Commission now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders during active litigation. ...This interpretation raises concerns that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms currently engaged in litigation and encouraging them to violate state and tribal gaming laws."

The letter also points out that the interpretation itself is a legal nonsense.

"There is no basis or precedent under 17 CFR 38.151(b)’s impartial access requirements for this interpretation and indeed this argument has been made in several of the active cases—and rejected."

As the senators' letter and McMahon's opinion allude to, the convenient readings of federal statutes by Selig for DCM operators' interests is an attempt to manipulate circumstances toward those same interests.

The legal arguments for DCMs like Kalshi and Polymarket being able to ignore state and tribal laws rest on two oft-rejected theories. The first is that all markets on the exchanges are "swaps" under federal law and that federal law preempts state statutes in regard to the regulation of swaps.

The legal test for preemption has two prongs: express and implied. Implied preemption itself has two categories, with those being conflict and field.

Neither the CEA nor the Dodd-Frank Act expressly state that the CFTC has regulatory powers over markets tied to the outcomes of events with financial ramifications to the exclusion of state or tribal law. Field preemption arguments fail because the CEA explicitly states that its tenets do not "supersede or limit the jurisdiction at any time conferred on the Securities and Exchange Commission or other regulatory authorities under the laws of the United States or of any State, or restrict the Securities and Exchange Commission and such other authorities from carrying out their duties and responsibilities in accordance with such laws."

Thus, conflict preemption remains the most viable path for the DCMs and Selig. Those pleas are increasingly finding little success, though.

Courts' rejection of conflict preemption claims

Conflict preemption occurs when it's impossible for an entity or individual to simultaneously comply with a federal law and a state law or if a state law is itself an obstacle to compliance with a federal statute.

McMahon isn't the only federal judge who has found the case for conflict preemption in this context lacking. In a summary judgement for the defendants in Kalshi v. Cox, federal district judge Robert J. Shelby addressed the notion that Kalshi couldn't comply with the CEA and Utah law simultaneously.

"Kalshi has not explained why or how it would be impossible to manage different State requirements. Indeed, Kalshi’s event contracts each contain an appendix of 'Trading Prohibitions'—some of which are specific to individual groups of people. Adding an additional category of prohibited participants in a sports-related event contract does not appear to be onerous. In short, Kalshi has not shown that compliance with both federal and state law is impossible."

Shelby also explains how Utah's laws banning gambling are not an obstacle to Kalshi's compliance with the CEA by pointing to the CFTC's own interpretation of impartial access at the time and pointing out that it has nothing to do with geography or any state laws.

"A DCM must provide its members access that is 'impartial, transparent, and applied in a non-discriminatory manner'; and members, traders, and software vendors must have '[c]omparable fee structures” for “receiving equal access to, or services from' the DCM. CFTC commentary shows the impartial access requirement is meant to prevent DCMs from discriminating based on monetary resources."

Selig's re-interpretation of impartial access isn't just convenient for corporations like Kalshi. It's an attempt to manufacture conflict preemption out of thin air.

Selig's interpretation invents crises for DCM operators

By re-interpreting impartial access to center on geography rather than financial circumstances, Selig's attempts to manipulate future court proceedings to his benefit and the benefit of DCM operators are plain. The aim is to manufacture a situation in which it's impossible for DCMs to comply with both federal and state laws.

However, as McMahon wrote, Selig's interpretation of the CEA is not the CEA itself. Panetta explains that concept.

"The CFTC has authority under the CEA to regulate swaps but [that] does not allow the agency to redefine the reach of its jurisdiction through regulatory announcements that go beyond the statute Congress enacted," Panetta commented. "Nor does a proposed rule carry the force of law that a category of contracts falls within the CFTC’s jurisdiction. Agencies can interpret and implement the laws Congress has passed, but courts have final say to determine if everything is consistent with the statute. The agency is the regulator so even though this [McMahon's opinion] is a preliminary injunction decision and remains subject to appellate review, [the] court has a clear boundary around the agency’s claimed authority. Federal regulatory jurisdiction is in the CEA’s actual language, not in the CFTC’s interpretation of it."

This is the exact situation that the senators described in their letter as well. These actions are timely because of the pending decisions from several federal circuit courts and the potential intervention of the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) in the legal dispute between DCMs/Selig and state governments.

Such blatant attempts to manipulate those rulings by propping up illusory crises must meet equally strong rejection. The question now is whether the judiciary and legislative branches have the resolution to follow through.

New year will set precedent for CFTC, DCMs for good or for ill

The early months of 2027 could be full of rulings from several federal appellate courts in a handful of cases over state sovereignty over prediction market exchanges. It could also see SCOTUS grant cert to an appeal.

Meanwhile, most of the senators who signed the letter to Selig will be part of the new Democratic majority in the chamber. Sen. Amy Klobuchar is resigning to serve as Minnesota's next governor and Sen. Gary Peters' term ends in January.

If courts give deference to Selig's legal nonsense for no reason other than his title or if the new Democratic majority fails to use its subpoena power to investigate the CFTC under Selig, that represents a further abdication of oversight. The fact that the CFT"C" has been a one-man operation and that it has directed DCMs to defy court orders should have already been sufficient reason for investigations.

What's more, Congress and the courts must be ready to enforce their orders with actual consequences. The demand that Selig preserve records is a good start, but only a start.

Of all the things that I'm here for, I'm the most here for McMahon's description of Selig's legal nonsense and the senators' letter to Selig. While Congress and the judiciary have nowhere to look but in the mirror in terms of how we got to this point, it's better late than never on restoring the balance.